Common cause mechanical deficiency in control rods


Print View Posted on: 19 June 2014

Event Date: 26 September 2013 Event Type: Research Reactor
Event Location: Netherlands, High Flux Reactor / Petten INES Rating: 2 (Final)

During an outage, on 26 September 2013, NRG reports the discovery of a deficiency in one of the six control rods of the High Flux Reactor (HFR) during an outage. Based on this discovery NRG decided to delay the restart of the reactor until the root cause and necessary measures were established and carried out. During the investigation two more control rods were found to show comparable deficiencies. The deficiencies could be traced back to an unreliable joining method of two main parts of the control rods. This has caused a limited amount of flexible kinking of these control rods inside the core.

In the event of the tripping of the main coolant pumps, for example due to a failure of the external power grid, a minimum of three of the six control rods is required to shut-down the reactor and reduce the produced heat in the reactor core. The presence of a common cause failure mechanism in all control rods that may hinder the free movement of the rods seriously reduces the reliability of this safety system.

NRG has performed an in-depth root-cause analysis of the discovered deficiencies. Based on the findings of this analysis it has improved the design of the control rods and taken measures to prevent reoccurrence of the event. Furthermore, NRG has initiated a large scale improvement program on technology, safety systems and the organization. On 14 February 2014 the reactor has resumed operation.

INES Rating: 2 - Incident (Final) as per 19 June 2014
Release beyond authorized limits? No
Overexposure of a member of the public? No
Overexposure of a worker? No

Contamination spread within the facility? No
Damage to radiological barriers (incl. fuel damage) within the facility? No

Degradation of Defence In-Depth Yes

Person injured physically or casualty? No
Is there a continuing problem? No

Yvonne van Leeuwen
Human Environment and Transport Inspectorate

yvonne.van.leeuwen@ILenT.nl
http://www.ilent.nl/english/
Site Sponsors
Site Sponsors: IAEA, NEA and WANO
This site is hosted by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) and co-sponsored by the Nuclear Energy Agency of the Organization of Economic Cooperation Development (OECD/NEA) and World Association of Nuclear Operators (WANO).
Disclaimer
This site is hosted by the IAEA, however, event reports are filed and updated by authorities in participating countries, which remain responsible for all related content. Read more >